Faith

caret-right

Women

caret-right

One Woman's Story

My Husband Woke Me Up at 2 AM and Said: "You're Not Done With God. You're Just Done Pretending."

I had tried 7 devotionals. Spent over $700. And felt like more of a failure every single time. Then something changed.

I told my husband I was walking away from Christianity. He said, "No you're not. You're just done faking."

I stared at him. Because he was right.

It was 2 AM on a Thursday and I was sitting on the edge of our bed in the dark because I didn't want to wake him up with my crying.

But he woke up anyway.

He found me there, bible open on my lap, the $123 leather-bound one I bought last January thinking maybe if it was beautiful enough I'd actually use it, and I was just staring at the pages like they were written in a language I'd never learned.

When he asked what was wrong, I said it. Out loud. For the first time.

"I think I'm done. I think I want to walk away from all of this."

He sat down next to me. Didn't say anything for a minute. Then: "You're not done with God. You're done pretending you're someone you're not."

And something inside me broke open.

Because I had been pretending. For years.

Pretending I had my quiet time together. Pretending I loved waking up at 5 AM to pray. Pretending the women's Bible study wasn't making me feel worse about myself every single week.

I'd been performing this version of Christianity that was killing me from the inside out. And I finally couldn't do it anymore.

Here's what I'd tried:

Every Bible-in-a-year plan on the internet. I'd restart in January, make it to February 11th, fall behind, feel too ashamed to catch up, and abandon it by March.

The YouVersion app with all the reading streaks. My longest streak was nine days. I watched that little flame icon disappear and felt like God was disappointed in me.

Prayer journals.

I bought four different ones over two years. Combined, I filled maybe 23 pages total. They're all in a drawer somewhere, reminders that I can't even journal consistently.

I joined an early morning prayer group that met at 6 AM on Tuesdays. I went three times. Then I started "forgetting" to set my alarm.

I bought the expensive Christian planner, the one all the influencers use with the Scripture memory verses and the "spiritual health tracker." It was $54. I used it for two weeks.

I even tried setting my coffee maker to auto-brew at 5 AM so I'd have an incentive to get up and "meet with Jesus." I just learned to sleep through the coffee smell.

In two years, I spent over $700 on devotionals, Bibles, journals, apps, online courses, and planners. Every single one of them promised to be the thing that would finally make me consistent.

Every single one made me feel like more of a failure.

And the worst part? I started avoiding the people at church who had it all figured out.

The woman who leads the women's ministry and posts Instagram photos of her Bible and coffee every morning at 5:15 AM with captions like "Starting my day in the Word."

The mom in my small group who always has something deep to share because she "spent time with the Lord" that morning.

My own mother-in-law, who's had the same quiet time routine for 30 years and never misses a day. Never.

I started dreading small group because someone would inevitably ask, "What's God been teaching you lately?" and I'd have to make something up or deflect.

I was drowning. And nobody knew.

Until that night. 2:37 AM. My husband seeing me for exactly what I was: exhausted. Done. Ready to walk away.

What he said next changed everything.

"Have you talked to Rachel?"

Rachel is my sister-in-law. And about six months ago, I noticed something about her.

She stopped posting those performative "quiet time" updates. She stopped talking about her Bible reading plan in that stressed-out way she used to. She just seemed lighter.

I asked her about it once, casually, and she said something like, "I finally stopped trying to impress God and just started showing up."

I didn't know what she meant at the time.

But sitting there at 2 AM with my husband, I texted her.

"Are you awake? I need to talk."

She called me immediately.

"I know exactly where you are," she said. "Because I was there. Sitting in my car in the church parking lot last year, crying because I couldn't make myself go inside one more time feeling like a fraud."

She told me about the same cycle I'd been in. The expensive devotionals. The failed Bible reading plans. The shame that got heavier every single day.

"I thought I was the only one," I said.

"You're not. Not even close."

Then she told me about something that saved her.

"I found this. And I know, I KNOW, you're probably rolling your eyes because you've tried devotionals. I tried 11 before this one. But this one is different."

I was skeptical. Of course I was. I'd heard "this one's different" before.

"What makes it different?" I asked. My voice was flat. Defeated.

"Because it's not designed to make you do more. It's designed to help you breathe."

She explained: The Invitation. Grace-based. Five minutes a day — but not five minutes of trying to prove yourself. Five minutes of being reminded you don't have to.

It's a lot less like a devotional and more like an invite to spend time with Jesus.

Just you and him.

"Wait, did it actually help you?" I said.

"Yeah. You can start any day. You can miss a day, a week, a month — and just pick it back up. No catching up. No guilt. No ruined streak."

That detail hit me like a truck. Because every other devotional I'd tried made me feel like if I missed one day, I'd destroyed everything.

"It's less than $40," she said. "Less than one therapy session. Less than two weeks of lattes. Less than that Bible study course you quit after week two."

I thought about the $700 I'd already spent. The shelf full of abandoned devotionals. The drawer full of empty journals.

"Here's the thing," Rachel said. "Every devotional you've tried taught you the old way: Read the Bible to prove you love God. This one teaches you the new way: Let God remind you He loves you. That shift changed everything for me."

Old way: Perform to earn. New way: Rest in what's already done.

I ordered it that night. 2 AM again. Couldn't sleep anyway.

It arrived three days later.

Day one was titled one word: Enough.

I sat there in my pajamas at 9 AM — not 5 AM, not after some perfect morning routine — and I read five minutes about the woman at the well. How she came at noon because she was too ashamed to face anyone. How she'd failed at everything. How Jesus met her there anyway.

The entry ended with this: "Your consistency doesn't determine God's love. His consistency does. And He's never missed a day of loving you."

I cried. But not the 2:37 AM kind of crying. This was different. Lighter.

I'd never believed I was enough before that morning.

After two weeks, I noticed something strange: I was actually looking forward to opening it.

Not because I had to. Not because I was trying to maintain a streak or prove something. Just because those five minutes felt like the only part of my day where I wasn't performing.

My husband noticed it first.

Three weeks in, he said, "You're not carrying that weight anymore, are you?"

I looked at him. "What weight?"

"The one that made you feel like you were failing God every single day. It's gone."

He was right.

I wasn't waking up with that immediate crush of guilt anymore. I wasn't avoiding church friends. I wasn't faking my way through small group.

It's been five months now.

I don't wake up at 5 AM. I don't have a perfect prayer routine. I still mess up. I still miss days sometimes.

But I'm not sitting on the edge of my bed at 2:37 AM wondering if I should just walk away from everything.

Because I finally understand: God never asked me to perform. He just wanted me to show up. Messy, inconsistent, broken, real.

And The Invitation taught me how to do that. Five minutes at a time. One day at a time. With so much grace I almost couldn't believe it.

If you're reading this and you're where I was — exhausted from trying, drowning in guilt, ready to walk away because you can't be the Christian everyone expects you to be —

You're not broken.

You're not a bad Christian.

You're just exhausted from trying to earn something that was already freely given.

What if you stopped trying to impress God and just started showing up?

I spent over $700 in two years on devotionals, Bibles, journals, apps, and courses that all made me feel worse about myself.

This book gave me my faith back.

365 days. No dates. You can start today, or tomorrow, or after the week that just wrecked you. Grace-based, so missing a day doesn't ruin everything. Five minutes, because that's all God needs to remind you who you already are to Him.

Less than one therapy session. Less than two lattes a week for a month. Less than that Bible study course you quit after week two.

This was made for women like us. Women who are tired of pretending. Women who need permission to stop performing.

You are already enough. You always have been.

Maybe it's time you believed it.

I left the link below. Think of it as one woman handing another woman the thing that finally helped.

Accept The Invitation

Article Written by

Amanda Johnson

@amanda.johnson1

The Invitation Buy One, Give One 50% Off